Some crypto investors are on the edge of financial ruin after trusting their nest eggs to two unregulated crypto marketplaces that went bankrupt.
Many put their life savings into virtual currency only to see their money frozen while the courts decide the fate of their investments.
Their plight has members of Congress calling for investor education and greater regulation.
Senators Debbie Stabenow, D-Mich., and John Boozman, R-Ark., introduced a bill Wednesday to give the Commodity Futures Trading Commission new tools and authorities to regulate digital commodities.
New laws will come too late for customers of Celsius Network and Voyager Digital.
One investor named Donald said he feels “completely ashamed and embarrassed” for sinking $31,000 into Voyager Digital Holdings.
“Losing this money with no end in sight has been unbearable for my family and I,” Donald said. “I wake up most nights and just walk up and down the stairs contemplating on my own mistakes and wondering if this will ever end.”
John Dalisay, who is paralyzed from the neck down, sent a letter to a judge saying he is depressed and unable to work after his life savings were frozen.
“I already suffered a tragic loss of my ability to ever walk again and did my best to be strong and fight to start over with my life,” Dalisay wrote. “I feel humiliated and defeated.”
Dalisay invested money from his $8-per-hour job at Celsius Network.
“I do not seek luxuries, your honor,” he wrote. “I only wanted to be able to afford basic necessities. Please help me be whole again as this situation Celsius created is wreaking havoc on my mental health.”
Voyager customers asked a judge to unfreeze their accounts. A hearing on that motion is scheduled for today.
Crypto lender Celsius and crypto broker Voyager Digital filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in July, freezing their customers’ assets. Celsius has 1.7 million customers and $6 billion in assets. Voyager counts 3.5 million users and over $5.9 billion of cryptocurrency assets.
Corporate bankruptcies are generally battles between rival groups of Wall Street investors backed by lawyers who often bill $1,000 or more per hour.
The Celsius and Voyager cases are exceptions. Everyday investors are flooding the courts with desperate pleas asking for their money back.
“There’s rarely enough money to cover the investor,” said Melanie Senter Lubin, president of the North American Securities Administrators Association, who testified last week at a Senate Banking Committee hearing on crypto fraud.
“If those investors are considered unsecured creditors, they’re going to be put in the pool with everybody else, and they’re typically at the end of the line.”
Safer than a bank?
Celsius and Voyager promoted the safety of their investments.
“Celsius stated overwhelmingly … that putting our funds into [their] custody was much safer than having it at a regular bank account,” wrote Paul Niehe, who transferred his pension savings into crypto.
Ryan Hourigan invested a portion of his paycheck into Voyager every month on top of rolling his life savings into his account.
“I used Voyager to replace my savings account as it was advertised as FDIC insured,” Hourigan said. “I am now filled with regret for doing so and fear that I pretty much lost everything for trusting this company.”
“They made astonishing claims, like offering up to 20% interest while claiming they were FDIC insured and quote ‘safer than banks,’” Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., said at last week’s hearing. “No risk. Twenty percent return. That was a lie from the start.”
They made astonishing claims, like offering up to 20% interest while claiming they were FDIC insured and quote, “safer than banks.” – Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass
The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) and the Federal Reserve have ordered Voyager to stop making false and misleading statements concerning its FDIC deposit insurance status and to take immediate corrective action.
Celsius allowed customers to get loans in real dollars by using their crypto holdings as collateral. Customers could also earn interest by lending their deposited coins, according to the company’s white paper.
Voyager offered a secure way to trade over 100 different crypto assets using a mobile app and advertised rewards on more than 40 cryptocurrencies, the company’s white paper said.
At least one person has turned to crowdfunding for help. Eduardo Dorrance wants to save his family’s animal rescue with a GoFundMe campaign. His family is a month away from losing the business.
Crypto winter
Crypto investors who used other platforms are not immune from losses.
Cryptocurrencies lost an estimated $2 trillion in value since peaking last year in a market collapse nicknamed the “crypto winter.”
Bitcoin, the biggest cryptocurrency, topped out at $68,789 per coin Nov. 10, 2021, before falling to a low of $17,709 June 18, according to CoinMarketCap data.
“It’s very important that people understand how a particular investment works, how they could lose money in the investment, what they pay for that investment, and what recourse they have,” Gerri Walsh, senior vice president of investor education at the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, said.
“When this is happening outside the space of regulation, the recourse of investors can be difficult.”
Walsh testified at the Senate hearing.
