Cramer Calls Lululemon a "Thoroughly Broken Stock"
Jim Cramer's September 10 verdict on Lululemon was unusually blunt for a name he once championed. The shares last closed at $98.97 after a 2.16% gain, and are down 52.48%.

On his September 10 Mad Money segment, Jim Cramer said Lululemon (NASDAQ: LULU) has gone "from one of the greatest growth stories ever told to a thoroughly broken stock" and that he could not give a good reason to buy it; the shares last closed at $98.97, up 2.16% on the session and down 52.48%.
Jim Cramer used his September 10 Mad Money segment to close the book on a stock he once held up as a model of American retail growth. "In less than three years, Lululemon has gone from one of the greatest growth stories ever told to a thoroughly broken stock," he said of Lululemon (NASDAQ: LULU), adding that "I can't give you a good reason to buy it."
That is about as final as the language gets on a nightly stock show, and it lands on a name whose chart already tells the story. Lululemon shares last closed at $98.97, a gain of 2.16% on the session, with a day range of $96.80 to $99.03 against a prior close of $96.88, according to market data as of the close on Friday, September 11. Measured against where the stock has been, the shares are down 52.48%.
A 2.16% up day inside a 52% drawdown
The session itself was green, and it comfortably cleared the broad market: the S&P 500 tracker (SPY) closed at $764.29, up 0.85%, the Nasdaq 100 tracker (QQQ) at $714.88, up 0.87%, and the Dow tracker (DIA) at $525.79, up 0.97%. All three finished near the upper end of their daily ranges. In other words, Lululemon's bounce came on a day when nearly everything worked, which is precisely the kind of move that tells an investor very little.
The distinction Cramer is drawing matters. A stock can rally within a downtrend for weeks without changing anything structural about the business underneath it. His argument, as delivered on air and summarized by 24/7 Wall St, is not that the shares are expensive on some multiple. It is that the narrative that justified the multiple has stopped working, and that nothing has replaced it.
What "broken" means when a host says it
"Broken stock" is a specific piece of Cramer's own vocabulary, and he has historically separated it from a "broken company." The first is a security whose price has detached from the fundamentals and can eventually be bought on weakness. The second is a business whose earning power has genuinely deteriorated, in which case the falling share price is the market doing its job rather than making a mistake.
The follow-on line — that he can't give a good reason to buy it — suggests he is not making the optimistic version of that call. A cheap stock with an identifiable catalyst is a recommendation. A cheap stock with no catalyst he can name is a pass. For a retail audience that has watched the position halve, that is a meaningfully different message from "be patient."
It is also a reversal. Lululemon spent years as a favored name among growth-oriented retail investors and on financial television generally, built on the premise that the brand could raise prices, expand internationally, and take share in athletic apparel without the discounting that afflicts most clothing retailers. A decline of this size implies the market no longer accepts at least one leg of that argument.
The questions a $98.97 print raises
Nothing in Cramer's remarks quantifies the deterioration, and no fresh company financials accompany them. What investors can do is frame the tests the stock now has to pass before the "broken" label comes off:
- North American comparable sales. The domestic business is the mature core. If traffic and per-store sales are still going the wrong way, international growth is filling a hole rather than adding to a base.
- Gross margin and markdowns. The premium pricing story is the whole investment case. Evidence of sustained promotion is what turns a de-rating into a permanent one.
- Inventory versus sales growth. Inventory building faster than revenue is the classic precursor to the discounting above.
- Guidance credibility. Repeated downward revisions cost a management team the benefit of the doubt, and that lost trust usually shows up as a lower multiple long after results stabilize.
- Cost inputs and trade policy. Apparel supply chains are exposed to tariff decisions that no retailer controls, and which can compress margins independent of demand.
None of those items is settled by a 2.16% session. They are settled by quarters.
How to treat a television verdict
Nothing in Cramer's remarks quantifies the deterioration, and no fresh company financials accompany them.
A broadcast opinion is not research, and it does not come with a price target or a model. What it does carry is influence over sentiment in a widely held consumer name, particularly one that a large retail cohort bought on the way up. When a prominent bull publicly withdraws, the marginal buyer who was waiting for reassurance may stop waiting.
The practical reading for anyone holding the stock is narrower than the headline suggests. The useful question is not whether a host has capitulated, but whether the holder can articulate the thing Cramer says he cannot: a specific, datable reason the business inflects. Brand-led apparel companies have recovered from drawdowns of this magnitude before, but the recoveries were driven by product cycles and margin repair, not by valuation alone.
Until one of those shows up in reported numbers, a stock that has lost 52.48% of its value and closed at $98.97 is doing what the market believes it should. The next set of quarterly results, and what management says about North American demand and pricing, will do far more to settle the argument than any single evening's commentary.
Frequently asked questions
What exactly did Jim Cramer say about Lululemon?
On his September 10 Mad Money segment, Cramer said: "In less than three years, Lululemon has gone from one of the greatest growth stories ever told to a thoroughly broken stock." He added that he "can't give you a good reason to buy it." The comments amounted to a withdrawal of support rather than a conditional hold recommendation.
Where is Lululemon stock trading now?
Lululemon shares last closed at $98.97, a gain of 2.16% on the session, from a prior close of $96.88. The day range ran from $96.80 to $99.03. Those are the most recent traded figures, as of the close on Friday, September 11, 2026. The stock is down 52.48%.
Did Lululemon outperform the market on its last trading day?
Lululemon rose 2.16% in its most recent session. On the same day, the S&P 500 tracker SPY closed at $764.29, up 0.85%, the Nasdaq 100 tracker QQQ at $714.88, up 0.87%, and the Dow tracker DIA at $525.79, up 0.97%. It was a broadly positive session across all three major benchmarks.
What does Cramer mean by a "broken stock"?
In Cramer's own long-used framing, a broken stock is one whose share price has fallen away from a business that is still intact, while a broken company is one whose earning power has genuinely deteriorated. The first can be bought on weakness; the second usually should not be. His refusal to name a reason to buy points away from the optimistic reading.
What should investors watch next in Lululemon's results?
The key items are North American comparable sales, gross margin and the level of markdowns, inventory growth relative to revenue, and whether management guidance proves reliable after any revisions. Apparel cost inputs and trade policy also affect margins independently of consumer demand. None of these are resolved by a single up session.
Is a television stock opinion the same as analyst research?
No. A broadcast verdict carries no published model, price target or formal rating, and it is not subject to the disclosure requirements that govern sell-side research. Its impact comes through sentiment, particularly in widely held consumer names with a large retail shareholder base. Investors should treat it as commentary, not as a substitute for company filings.
Sources
- Jim Cramer: Lululemon Is a “Thoroughly Broken Stock. I Can’t Give You a Good Reason to Buy It” — 24/7 Wall St
Photo: Photo Eddie O. · Pexels Licence — source


